The real cause and impact of China’s labour shortage

Beijing Forbidden City

Forbidden City, Beijing. Photo: Craig Hill

China continues to suffer a labour shortage in its key coastal manufacturing regions. This, no doubt, is impacting U.S. and other foreign companies operating in China. But the labour shortage is not due to a lack of available workers. Instead, it is prompted by Chinese government policies, as well as prevailing work and living conditions in affected regions.

The Alienation of Migrant Workers

During the last two decades of China’s development, rural workers migrating to urban manufacturing regions have been the chief source of labour in coastal cities. According to the Chinese government’s, own statistics, migrant workers have increased to more than 250 million from just over 60 million in the last 20 years. Many non-government organisations place this number at a more realistic 350 to 400 million.

Even with a massive number of workers available nationally, China Daily recently reported that labour shortages are growing worse in cities like Guangzhou and Shanghai. In these areas, there is an estimated 30 to 70 percent gap between the number of workers demanded and the number available. Chinese news reports also reiterate that an increasing number of workers previously employed on the coast are now actively seeking work in interior provinces closer to their birth counties.

The hard truth: most migrant workers are no longer incentivised to travel to these cities for employment when they can achieve equal or better results working closer to home.

In urban areas, workers from the countryside are not afforded legal protection. An antiquated Hukou (household registration) system bars outsiders from taking part in a city’s basic social infrastructure. Migrants cannot utilise local childcare, education, housing, medical, or unemployment benefits. To take advantage of urban benefits such as accredited schools or proper hospitals, migrants must pay “usage fees” often equal to more than a year’s worth of wages.

According to both UN and Chinese studies, the cost of living is generally two times higher in coastal urban areas in comparison to China’s interior. These studies also demonstrate wages for factory workers are, on average, nearly 50 percent higher in coastal cities (not including mandatory overtime) and fail to compensate for living expenses.

The low wage to cost of living ratio combined with the lack of legal status makes it extremely difficult to live and work in coastal cities for extended periods of time. This is especially true if workers wish to move their families to these high-cost metropolitan areas in hopes of achieving a higher standard of living. Unfortunately, migrant worker ghettos, where families live outside of the regular chain of existence, are the tragic norm in many urban regions.

Flaws in IMF Reporting

A new report by the International Monetary Fund (IMF) predicts China will endure a full-scale nationwide labour shortage by 2025. While the report identifies the current Hukou system as a key issue in labour reform, it relies far too heavily on official Chinese government statistics many Chinese government officials themselves question.

New premier Li Keqiang is quoted in a leaked 2007 U.S. diplomatic cable as calling China’s official statistics “man-made.” Reliance on suspect data casts the IMF’s empirically based study in doubt. Although many coastal cities have high employment rates, evidence on the ground suggests China does not have a “national” labor shortage and will not have one in fifteen years’ time.

Four key factors overlooked by the IMF report identify issues the international business community should be aware of. These include the following:

  1. The popular belief that there is a near equilibrium between Chinese labour supply and demand is inaccurate. China does not really have the official 87 percent employment rate. Any report utilising this figure at the root of its calculations will be misleading.
  2. In reality, a large portion of China’s population remains either vastly underemployed or untracked for employment statistics. A significant sector of the population holds multiple jobs, works in completely unreported industries, and/or is paid off the books.
  3. The IMF study also underestimates the impact of changes to the Chinese retirement age. Many workers who are forced to retire in their late forties and early fifties generally continue to work after retiring, especially in urban areas. These retirees typically work off the books and are statistically untracked. Given this consideration, changing the retirement age may not fill as much of the labour demand as the report estimates.
  4. There has been a massive spike in unemployment and underemployment in Chinese university graduates. By some estimates, at least half of all university graduates in China over the past three years are unemployed or underemployed.

Addressing Labor Concerns

Issues currently facing China are due more to bureaucracy than to decreased birth rates or forecasted decreases in population. Reforming the Hukou system and guaranteeing workers basic rights in urban areas will likely provide fast and immediate alleviation of any current labour shortages facing coastal areas.

As the Chinese population inevitably declines due to the one child policy, the retirement age also may be adjusted in accordance with economic need. Additionally, proper statistics that better reflect the on-the-ground employment situation will foster an improved understanding of China’s future labour trends.

Foreign firms operating in China can play a positive role in improving this situation as well. While firms can provide higher pay or missing societal infrastructure to workers, these alone will not overcome the problem. Foreign companies in China would be wise to work with their respective chambers of commerce to advocate changes and improvements to the outdated Hukou system.

The IMF and other international organisations also could actively encourage China to amend the Hukou system. Additionally, instead of creating unnecessary alarm over current or forecasted labour shortages, the IMF could concentrate on partnering with China to align its educational system with the skill sets required for success in the 21st century. Tomorrow’s employees are being trained for the last decade’s marketplace rather than the marketplace of the future. This is a problem China is not alone in facing.

Article Originally from The Manzella Report

Categories: Education & Employment

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

4 replies

  1. Reblogged this on CHINDIA ALERT: You'll be living in their world, very soon and commented:
    So far this labour shortage has not had a significant impact on the economy. But if ignored, it will.


  2. Reblogged this on middlekingdom1of10boyz and commented:
    Another challenge that is caused at least in some part by the HuKou.



  1. China to expand unemployment benefits to lure migrants to cities | China Daily Mail

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: