A showdown is looming in Hong Kong, with China threatening to send in its army

Hong Kong at night

Hong Kong at night

For years after the return of Hong Kong to Chinese sovereignty in 1997, China’s leaders surprised the world by adhering scrupulously to Hong Kong’s unusual political set-up of “one country, two systems”.

Under the terms of the handover, Hong Kong was to retain a high degree of autonomy for 50 years, an ingenious solution for reintegration of a former colony.

In recent years, however, party leaders in Beijing have become less respectful of that system, and that is stirring up resentment.

On June 22nd a protest group called Occupy Central will hold an informal referendum on Hong Kong’s politics. Since 1997 Hong Kong’s chief executive has been chosen by a hand-picked committee of 1,200 local worthies, all friends of Beijing. China has promised that in 2017 the choice will be by “universal suffrage”, but it still insists that the candidates must be chosen by the worthies. This weekend’s referendum offers voters three choices, all of which give Hong Kongers the right to choose the candidates. Occupy Central says it will promote the most popular option. China has said none is acceptable.

To add spice to all this, the regime in Beijing has issued a white paper reminding the territory that Hong Kong’s “autonomy” is entirely at the discretion of China’s leaders. It adds that the judiciary is part of the government and has a “basic political requirement” to “be patriotic”. That flies in the face of Hong Kong’s independent judiciary and its common-law, English legal system. The response of many Hong Kongers has been more angry than at anything since 1997. Occupy Central has threatened to bring the business district to a standstill.

It will come as no great surprise that many think the chief executive should be chosen democratically. The Beijing government would have done better to stick to its original promise, not least because in a free election Hong Kongers would have probably chosen a pro-China candidate anyway. Now that such an election is an impossibility, both sides should be looking for a way to climb down.

When A Panda Throws Its Weight Around

For the democracy activists, that means accepting that most Hong Kongers are pragmatists. However suspicious they are of the Communist Party, they are also disinclined to back radical street politics. Hong Kong is still freer (and richer) than the rest of China. Provoking a clampdown hardly seems wise.

But neither is China’s hardline stance. Many Hong Kongers moved towards the radicals’ camp after a senior mainland figure talked about dealing with disorder by sending in the Chinese army. Attacking the independence of the judiciary in the white paper was also barmy, even by the undemocratic regime’s own aims. The economy is still its priority, and Hong Kong is its most global financial centre. Rule of law and press freedom are the foundations of Hong Kong’s prosperity (and a reason why Shanghai still has not caught up). If China’s president, Xi Jinping, is serious about fighting corruption, then he should be working out how the legal system of the rest of the country can become more like Hong Kong’s.

China is harming itself in other ways. By breaking promises to Hong Kong, it is hardly reassuring Taiwanese voters that “one country, two systems” could be the basis for reunification. And by throwing its weight around, it is doing nothing for its image as a bully in the region. This week an attempt to patch up things with Vietnam failed noisily. A showdown in Hong Kong will not help China’s peaceful rise.

Source: Business Insider – A Showdown Is Looming Between Hong Kong And China

Categories: Human Rights & Social Issues

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

40 replies

  1. Is it still official law for all Hong Kongese to learn Kung Fu? China’s army might be going into one of those Chinese Finger traps Hong Kong-style 🙂 PS Its an honor to have been invited to write on China Daily Mail. I have been interested in China and south east Asia since I was a kid. and I still am. one more thing I want to add:

    Approx 25 million Chinese men will soon experience the loneliness not finding a Chinese gf/wife due to that old Chinese Government one child policy. Now they start wondering South to Vietnam and neighboring Counties in search of traditional Asian women. MY QUESTION IS: Was that one child policy in fact just so south east Asia could become Chinese-nized?



  1. Hong Kong: 600,000 defy China in ‘vote’ for democracy | China Daily Mail
  2. Hong Kong has nothing to learn from China, but China has much to learn from Hong Kong | China Daily Mail
  3. China’s police given guns; irresponsible shootings result | China Daily Mail
  4. Hong Kong’s Occupy Central ‘Referendum’ Explained | pundit from another planet
  5. Buying a job in China’s army costs $16,000 for those that fail entry tests | China Daily Mail
  6. Huge crowds turn out to call for democracy in Hong Kong | China Daily Mail
  7. On day of Hong Kong mass protests, China shows military strength by opening barracks to public | China Daily Mail
  8. The battle against China for Hong Kong’s soul | China Daily Mail
  9. China, Hong Kong and Cantonese: Dialect dialectic | China Daily Mail
  10. Free Elections for Hong Kong | pundit from another planet
  11. Prelude to Conflict: Asia, July 28 | China Daily Mail
  12. Prelude to Conflict: Asia, August 4 | China Daily Mail
  13. CHINA’S Ticking Clock: Critical Hong Kong Vote Ruling by Beijing Coming Soon | pundit from another planet
  14. [PHOTOS] EXCLUSIVE: Images From the Hong Kong Pro-Democracy Rally | pundit from another planet
  15. Hong Kong braces for protests as China rules out full democracy | China Daily Mail
  16. Prelude to Conflict: Asia, September 1 | China Daily Mail
  17. China sends armoured carriers into Hong Kong Streets amidst democracy protests | China Daily Mail
  18. Prelude to Conflict: Asia, September 8 | China Daily Mail
  19. Do the Chinese love China? | China Daily Mail
  20. China asserts paternal rights over Hong Kong in democracy clash; Hong Kong must obey | China Daily Mail
  21. Prelude to Conflict: Asia, September 15 | China Daily Mail
  22. Prelude to Conflict: Asia, September 29 | China Daily Mail
  23. Protests in Hong Kong caused by China failing to honour its promises | China Daily Mail
  24. Hong Kong college students take the lead in fighting for true democracy | China Daily Mail
  25. An open letter to the Chinese Communist Party regarding the Hong Kong protests | China Daily Mail
  26. China warns of ‘unimaginable consequences’ if Hong Kong demonstrations continue | China Daily Mail
  27. Hong Kong music: Clockenflap and PUSH collaborate on new project | China Daily Mail
  28. Is this the end of China’s economic miracle? | China Daily Mail
  29. Hong Kong: Pearl of China | China Daily Mail
  30. China’s boom is over, and here’s what you can do about it | China Daily Mail
  31. Prelude to Conflict: Asia, January 26 | China Daily Mail
  32. Twice as many expatriates leaving China than arriving, as China loses its appeal | China Daily Mail
  33. Prelude to Conflict: Asia, February 16 | China Daily Mail
  34. China to tighten control of Hong Kong? | China Daily Mail
  35. Prelude to Conflict: Asia, March 9, 2015 | China Daily Mail
  36. Mass suicide bid by 30 Chinese cabbies in Beijing was caused by government indifferenceif | China Daily Mail
  37. Mexican drug cartels have infiltrated Hong Kong | China Daily Mail

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: