Massive spending won’t make China’s Asia dream come true; money can’t buy respect

So far, though, it seems Xi only wants to pay the region to realize that China has Asia’s back in ways that Barack Obama’s America and Shinzo Abe’s Japan can’t afford

So far, though, it seems Xi only wants to pay the region to realize that China has Asia’s back in ways that Barack Obama’s America and Shinzo Abe’s Japan can’t afford

After two years of waxing poetic at home about a “China Dream,” Xi Jinping wants to enchant the entire Asia region—and is dangling $1.25 trillion to make sure he does.

“China’s development will bring huge opportunities and benefits to the Asia-Pacific and the world, President Xi told business leaders in Beijing on Sunday. “We are willing to work with others to realise the Asia-Pacific Dream.”

So far, though, it seems Xi only wants to pay the region to realise that China has Asia’s back in ways that Barack Obama’s America and Shinzo Abe’s Japan can’t afford. That $1.25 trillion is the total in outbound investments China plans to make over the next 10 years. Beijing is also lavishing $40 billion to recreate the Silk Road to bolster trade with Europe. A $50 billion infrastructure fund will make the World Bank and Asian Development Bank look like archaic vestiges of a bygone geopolitical age. And China’s Free Trade Area of the Asia- Pacific is timed to rival the US-led Trans-Pacific Partnership.

But Beijing’s financial charm offensive lacks one crucial element: love. Its $4 trillion of currency reserves and rapid growth buys China lots of attention and any meeting it wants—just not the affectionate “soft power” it craves. This won’t come via spending or from China’s rising clout. It will come from actions worthy of a more mature, reasonable and civil global stakeholder.

“Through trade and investment, China has been able to bind many emerging Asian economies to its own,” explains Rajiv Biswas, chief Asia economist at IHS Global Insight in Singapore. But it has undermined its own efforts to establish Chinese leadership in Asia through “poorly managed, inward-looking political and military posturing.”

China is embroiled in territorial disputes with Vietnam, the Philippines and several other members of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations, or ASEAN(Japan, too, of course). These entanglements often do more harm than Beijing’s largess helps. The same is true of Beijing’s moves to scrutinise foreign companies from Microsoft Corp. to Toyota Motor Corp., silence the international media and police cyberspace. China’s heavy-handed response to Hong Kong’s pro-democracy movement hardly projects secure, confident power.

Genuine affection comes from acting in partnership with Asian neighbours, not buying their loyalty with the odd multi- billion-dollar dam, bridge, road or power grid. For years, China tossed money at unsavoury regimes and looked the other way as environmental and labour protections were ignored. Yet if China wants to buttress its soft power, it should consider following the Japanese model.

No, huge infrastructure projects aren’t altruism. But Japan has long provided governments like India or Indonesia the money and technical expertise to upgrade their own infrastructure in ways that enrich local economies. That means using local materials and labour, as opposed to Beijing’s preference that countries import both from China. It surprised no one in August to hear Joko Widodo, then Indonesia’s President-elect, calling Japan “our largest partner” and urging more investment to ramp up a $46 billion bilateral trade relationship.

Since taking office in December 2012, Japanese Prime Minister Abe has visited all 10 ASEAN members. Last December, Japan pledged $20 billion in Southeast Asia investments over five years. Abe has since shifted billions in foreign-direct investment from China to Southeast Asia.

Before Xi can realize his Asia-Pacific Dream, he has to define it. Even many of his 1.3 billion people are confused about what their domestic China Dream entails. Does it refer to building a modern, prosperous, more egalitarian society? Is Xi suggesting his masses should harbour American-style aspirations like owning a home? Or is it just a rhetorical device that contains more than a whiff of nationalism on the part of a leader fond of cribbing Mao Zedong speeches? No one can say for sure—at least not yet.

Xi’s broader dream lacks both clarity and the toolkit necessary to win Asia’s love. Much of emerging Asia may want China to lead regional economic development, but that can’t happen until Asia’s largest economy reconsiders its inward- looking political and military policies.

Source: Live Mint – Spending won’t make China’s Asia dream come true

Categories: Trade & Investment

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

13 replies

  1. If the common Chinese is confused of what the “China Dream” is and most Asians are breaking records to upgrade their national defense preparedness for such “dream”, a smart Xi should have toned down on his dream theme and quietly, invested his trillions on social net establishment, economic equality for the mass, clean up of killers pollution and lessons on world civilization… but no – a not so smart Xi is exposing the real “Middle Kingdom” China with his Asia-Pacific dream, which no doubt includes but not limited some Japanese islets, 90% of South China Sea, whatever borders region with India and the Silk road that efficiently, exports hungry Chinese all the way to Indonesia and beyond.



  1. China makes public its dream for Greater Asia Co-prosperity Sphere | China Daily Mail
  2. In veiled message to China, Obama renews commitment to Asia-Pacific pivot | China Daily Mail
  3. Australia and China sign landmark free trade deal | China Daily Mail
  4. Why China will never be Asia’s dominant power | China Daily Mail
  5. China’s diplomatic blitzkrieg against the US at APEC summit may not be as successful as China believes | China Daily Mail
  6. Microsoft closing two China factories and relocating to Vietnam; another 9,000 jobs lost | China Daily Mail
  7. China’s SWIFT alternative (CIPS) and the engineered death of the dollar | China Daily Mail
  8. Asia’s dominance in manufacturing will endure – that will make development harder for others | China Daily Mail
  9. US, Australia and Philippines start war games in South China Sea amid China tensions | China Daily Mail
  10. China and Russia to build moon base as counter to US and Japanese plans | China Daily Mail
  11. US says China cyber attacks are ‘unacceptable’ and US will win online confrontation | China Daily Mail
  12. China says it should join TPP, even though it wasn’t invited | China Daily Mail

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: