Vietnam launches legal challenge against China’s South China Sea claims

Tensions between China and Vietnam were stretched in may when China parked an oil rig in Vietnam's Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ)

Tensions between China and Vietnam were stretched in may when China parked an oil rig in Vietnam’s Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ)

Vietnam and China moved their sabre-rattling over the South China Sea into the legal arena this week as Hanoi lodged a submission with an arbitral tribunal at The Hague and rejected a Chinese position paper. Beijing swiftly dismissed Vietnam’s challenge.

In a statement on Thursday, the Vietnamese foreign ministry rejected China’s December 7 position paper, which laid out Beijing’s legal objections to an arbitration case that the Philippines had filed against it.

“Vietnam’s established position is to resolutely object to China’s claims over Hoang Sa, Truong Sa islands and adjacent waters,” Vietnamese foreign ministry spokesman Le Hai Binh said, using the Vietnamese names for the Paracel and Spratly Islands.

Binh also suggested that Hanoi had sent a statement to the Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA) at The Hague, which is currently examining the Philippines’ case against China over the South China Sea disputes.

According to the South China Morning Post, Vietnam’s statement to the PCA, submitted last Friday, made three main claims in opposition to China’s stand. First, it recognised the court’s jurisdiction over the case submitted by the Philippines, which Beijing does not. Second, it requested that the court give “due regard” to Vietnam’s own legal rights and interests in the Spratlys, Paracels, and in its exclusive economic zone and continental shelf while deliberating on the case. Third and lastly, it rejected China’s infamous nine-dash line – which lays claim to about 90 percent of the South China Sea – as being “without legal basis.”

Hanoi’s actions are part of a concerted effort to respond to China’s growing assertiveness in the South China Sea, which has continued in 2014. In May, a Chinese state-owned oil company dispatched a deep sea drilling rig off the coast of Vietnam in disputed waters south of the Paracel Islands, which led to deadly boat clashes and anti-Chinese violence and plunged diplomatic relations to an all-time low. In response, Vietnamese prime minister Nguyen Tan Dung had said that Hanoi was “considering various actions, including legal actions in accordance with international law.”

By lodging a statement with the court – as opposed to directly joining the Philippines in its case – Vietnam has found a way to make its views heard but not alienate Beijing, which has warned Hanoi against joining Manila’s legal challenge. Beyond the legal realm, Vietnam has also taken a number of other actions, including slowly moving towards closer ties with the United States – made easier by the partial lifting of a U.S. lethal weapons embargo – and making its first-ever port call to the Philippines last month.

Predictably, China dismissed Vietnam’s sovereignty claims in its foreign ministry statement, labelling them “illegal and invalid” and emphasising that “China will never accept such a claim.”

“China urges Vietnam to earnestly respect our territorial sovereignty and maritime rights and resolve relevant disputes regarding Nansha with China on the basis of respecting historical facts and international law so as to jointly maintain peace and stability on the South China Sea,” Chinese foreign ministry spokesman Hong Lei said, using the Chinese name for the Spratly Islands.

The legal tussle between Beijing and Hanoi comes as the December 15 deadline nears for China to submit its defence in the arbitration case brought about by the Philippines. China is not expected to submit anything in response to the tribunal’s deadline, having already declared in its position paper that it would “neither accept nor participate in the arbitration.”

Two days before China released its position paper, the U.S. State Department published a study that questioned the validity of Beijing’s nine-dash line. China dismissed the study, claiming that it ignored basic facts and legal principles and was unhelpful in resolving the South China Sea issue.

Source: The Diplomat – Vietnam Launches Legal Challenge Against China’s South China Sea Claims

Categories: Politics & Law

Tags: , , , , , , ,

13 replies


  1. Will South China Sea dispute arbitration bring peace to the region? | China Daily Mail
  2. NGO weighs legal action after Chinese police raid its offices | China Daily Mail
  3. US to deploy nuclear-capable bombers to Australia to send message to China | China Daily Mail
  4. China responds US ‘provocations’ in South China Sea by a direct challenge, increasing building on artificial islands | China Daily Mail
  5. Official news in China stresses military use of Fiery Cross Reef in South China Sea, mocks United States | China Daily Mail
  6. Chinese media report: China angered by new US military strategy report | China Daily Mail
  7. A worried China tries to urge Philippines to ditch its South China Sea case | China Daily Mail
  8. China told to behave in the South China Sea … or else | China Daily Mail
  9. Malaysia joins the stand against China in South China Sea dispute | China Daily Mail
  10. South China Sea: China creates facts, builds ground to serve them. | China Daily Mail
  11. US says China will be bound by maritime arbitration ruling in South China Sea | China Daily Mail
  12. The U.S. just sent a carrier strike group to confront China in the South China Sea | China Daily Mail
  13. China denies US aircraft carrier entry to Hong Kong, no reason given | China Daily Mail

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: