Asean chief says ‘can’t accept’ China’s South China Sea claims

Association of Southeast Asian Nations Secretary-General Le Luong Minh on Nov. 11, 2014. Mr. Minh said Asean would speed up talks to establish a code of conduct on how to resolve overlapping territorial claims in the region.

Association of Southeast Asian Nations Secretary-General Le Luong Minh on Nov. 11, 2014. Mr. Minh said Asean would speed up talks to establish a code of conduct on how to resolve overlapping territorial claims in the region.

The secretary-general of Southeast Asia’s 10-member trade and security bloc Sunday said the group can’t agree to China’s use of its so-called nine-dash line to claim the contested waters of the South China Sea as Beijing continues its land-reclamation efforts in the area.

China’s island-building project in the Spratly Islands in particular has raised concerns that it is trying to enforce control of an area where the Philippines, Vietnam and other countries also claim territory. Satellite images released earlier this month indicate that China has begun building a concrete runway on reclaimed land built up around a disputed reef, according to defence intelligence provider IHS Jane’s.

Beijing claims nearly the entire South China Sea as its own, using a tongue-shaped nine-dash line that it says reflects the country’s historic territory.

The Association of Southeast Asian Nations “could not accept the dash line” because it isn’t compatible with international law, Le Luong Minh said in an interview as the group’s two-day leaders summit gets under way in Malaysia. He said both the territorial line, which appears on some Chinese maps and claims wide areas of the region where nations such as Vietnam and the Philippines have claims, and China’s recent reclamation efforts in the sea run counter to a 13-year-old agreement between China and Asean.

Mr. Minh said Asean would also speed up talks to establish a code of conduct on how to resolve overlapping territorial claims in the potentially energy-rich region, which is also home to around half the world’s commercial shipping lanes. Beijing, however, appears reluctant to participate. “We have not been able to engage China in more substantive discussions,” he said, but suggested that Asean wouldn’t directly criticise China over the course of the summit.

The Philippines, though, has challenged China’s claims at the United Nations, which is scheduled to decide in July whether a tribunal should hear the Philippines’ protest.

South China Sea

South China Sea

China’s foreign ministry last month criticised Mr. Minh, a Vietnamese national who was named head of Asean in 2013, for suggesting China’s reclamation efforts in the South China Sea contravene international law. In recent months, China has been adding sand to reefs in the region to create outposts that it says will help its fishermen.

Mr. Minh’s dismissed Beijing’s suggestion that he maintain the group’s neutrality.

“What kind of neutrality [are they] talking about? Can I be neutral to Asean interests?” he said. “How can I be neutral to truth?”

The status of uninhabited land and reefs in the South China Sea “must not be changed,” he added.

The Asean leaders are expected to discuss other issues during the summit, including regional conflicts and the formal, partial advent of a regional economic zone by the end of this year that lowers tariffs and barriers to labour movement and investment.

Mr. Minh said the group is still drafting an official statement for the summit, but it will include an “expression of concern” about issues affecting peace and stability in the region and will call, as it has in the past, for a swift conclusion to talks on a legally binding code of conduct in the South China Sea, originally made a goal in 2002.

Asked about U.S.’s attempts to boost connections with Asia in recent years, he said the U.S. “has been playing a constructive role in the region,” and that he hoped the relationship “can be enhanced, contributing to the maintenance of peace and stability.”

On other matters, Mr. Minh said Asean welcomes new sources of funding, such as the still-forming Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank led by Beijing, to help the region meet needs for around $100 billion in annual financing for infrastructure.

Mr. Minh added that the group hasn’t discussed the location of a headquarters for the bank, which Indonesia, Southeast Asia’s largest economy, has been pushing to place in Jakarta.

Source: Wall Street Journal – Asean Chief Says ‘Can’t Accept’ Beijing’s South China Sea Claims


Categories: Politics & Law

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

8 replies

  1. This is the latest proof of how ASEAN has become irrelevant in addressing the complexity of 21st century and remains useful tool for Chinese territorial expansionist aggressions:
    . ASEAN appoints skilled and professional caliber leader as its chief for 10-years term while rotating through 10 different 1-year member/national host with diversified ranges of interest, size, ideology, hidden agenda and/or even political courage.
    . Like his Thai predecessor, Mr. Minh is a 30-years career diplomat with impressive rank of Under Secretary and unmatched regional knowledge base, technical capability not only to manage current ASEAN agenda but, to jointly develop long-term vision. The contradiction is obvious when his legitimate assessment of baseless Chinese claim and its military bases construction is violating 2002DOC, often crashes with Chinese well-paid-client Cambodia in 2013, muted smaller-than-a-Chinese-village Brunei in 2014 and current Chinese-aggressor-but-let’s-not-offend Malaysia. In fact, even the strongest ASEAN member Indonesia (honest broker) or the wealthiest co-founder Singapore (1 vote from becoming the next Chinese Crimea)…can’t risk being victimized by Chinese in their 1-year short reign, cowardly passing the hot potato down the line.
    Accordingly, principled members of ASEAN such as the Philippines and Vietnam, who share common view of this imminent Chinese danger with the rest of civilized world must now look for alliance elsewhere: other Asian powers Australia, Japan and India…Once such counter-force is formed, undoubtedly the rest of ASEAN will follow – except, of course Cambodia and Singapore will be happily remained as vassal Chinese states.



  1. China told to behave in the South China Sea … or else | China Daily Mail
  2. Malaysia joins the stand against China in South China Sea dispute | China Daily Mail
  3. Cadence of Conflict: Asia, January 6, 2015 | China Daily Mail
  4. Cadence of Conflict: Asia, February 22, 2016 | China Daily Mail
  5. China criticises US, Japan, Australia for ‘fanning’ tensions in South China Sea | China Daily Mail
  6. Cadence of Conflict: Asia, April 25, 2016 | China Daily Mail

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: