Putting China’s debt into perspective

Putting China's debt into perspective

Putting China’s debt into perspective

China’s total debt quadrupled between 2007 and 2014, which was about one-third of the $57 trillion in debt added globally during that period. Can this possibly be safe?

To answer this question, the McKinsey Global Institute devotes an entire chapter to China’s debt in the new report Debt and (not much) deleveraging. The key issue is whether China can slow the growth of debt without unduly crimping GDP growth, which already has fallen to the lowest rate in nearly a quarter century (see my Jan. 27 post here).

Our conclusion is that China’s debt situation warrants careful monitoring. In broad terms, China’s debt has moved from a developing economy level (158 percent of GDP in 2007) to advanced-economy status (282 percent in 2014, a bit higher than the United States and Germany). Not only does the speed of this debt buildup raise alarms, so does its composition. Almost half of new debt is flowing into the property sector and related industries, and around 30 percent of debt is provided by a shadow banking industry, whose lending standards and exposures are not easily discerned.

That’s not ideal but it may be manageable. Household and government debt are both low, even by the standards of developing economies, while debt of non-financial corporations is high. China has the financial wherewithal to weather a debt-induced crisis. And China’s government is taking steps to reduce the risk of crisis.


The report focuses on three areas of potential risk: a concentration of debt in the property sector; reliance on shadow banking; and the large debts of local governments.

China's debt to GDP

China’s debt to GDP

Real estate

Nearly half the new debt in China since 2007 has gone to real estate development or related industries such as steel and cement. Now, the property sector is cooling off. The value of residential real estate transactions in 40 Chinese cities, after rising 26 percent per year for 10 years, fell by 14 percent from April 2013 to August 2014—and by more than 30 percent in Beijing and Shenzhen.

While Chinese households are not, in general, over-extended with mortgage debt, a deep and prolonged housing slump could have huge impact on the construction sector, which accounts for 15 percent of GDP and includes tens of thousands of small players who would not be able to meet their debt obligations. The steel and cement industries, which already have excess capacity, would also suffer.

Shadow banking

The so-called shadow banking system—consisting of unregulated non-bank lenders—accounts for 30 percent of all new credit since 2007. Shadow banks, such as trust companies, raise money from wealthy investors seeking high returns and lend to players in real estate as well as to companies that cannot qualify for bank loans.

Not only is shadow banking concentrated in real estate, the quality of its underwriting is not known—nor is the total exposure of shadow banks. One trust company missed its payment to investors because a single borrower—a steel company—missed a payment.

Local governments

As a result of China’s rapid urbanisation and limitations on how local governments can raise revenue, the debt of local government in China has grown to more than $2.8 trillion. About $1.7 trillion of this is owed by local government financing vehicles, off-balance sheet entities that are used to fund investments in infrastructure, social housing, and other types of construction.

The ability of some local governments to pay back their debts is in question: a 2014 audit found that more than 20 percent of recent loans were used to pay older debts and that almost 40 percent of debt servicing and repayments were funded by land sales.

Chinese policy makers are certainly aware of the risks associated with unsustainable debt and are taking steps to reduce them. The government has imposed punitive interest rates for mortgages on second homes, and banned purchases of third homes to cool off the real estate market . (However, facing slower growth, the central bank cut interest rates last fall—illustrating the tension between growth and safety).

In shadow banking, the government has imposed stricter product marketing rules on trust companies. To reduce reliance on land sales and LGFVs, the government has allowed cities to issue municipal bonds (on a limited basis). The state also has changed the incentives for local governments, emphasising sustainable economic development, social harmony, and environmental protection, which takes pressure off cities to build more costly infrastructure. If these measures are sufficient—and are implemented consistently—China’s debt might remain merely a potential concern for the global economy.

Source: McKinsey Greater China Putting China’s Debt Into Perspective


Categories: Finance & Economy

Tags: , , , , , , ,

3 replies

  1. You cannot compare Chinese debt to U.S. debt. China’s debt unlike the U.S. is all internal. The U.S. has sold it’s debt all over the world. China’s debt is almost all owed by local governments and SOE’s. There is little to no private or central government debt. Since almost all debt is owned by the State itself it cannot default, although it does not need to. It still runs a surplus and has more than enough foreign reserves as a cushion if need be. It holds a total of almost 4 trillion in foreign exchange reserves mostly in the U$D. That is about 24 – 26 Trillion RMB.

    So unlike the U.S. China’s debt is not a concern for anyone outside of China as it does not owe anyone outside China. China unlike the U.S. and many other countries has no outside creditors. At least none of any consequence. Think of it as lending money to a member of your family or a friend. The only one that needs to be concerned about the debt being repaid is you.



  1. This is how China is trying to save its economy | China Daily Mail
  2. Understanding the two Chinas | China Daily Mail

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

<span>%d</span> bloggers like this: